Showing posts with label prose. Show all posts
Showing posts with label prose. Show all posts

Friday, July 8, 2022

What Is Missing--The Lipogram

Gadsby (novel) - Wikipedia

(Note: links with a star next to them will take you to Amazon pages where you can buy the books in question.)

A lipogram is a kind of rule-based writing in which the author does not use a particular letter. Most of the world's poetry is written using constraints--such as particular rhythms, rhyme schemes, etc.--and this is simply one of the poetic tools you can use. 

 Whenever I have taught writing, I have always given an assignment in which the students were to write a one-page essay without using any words that contain the letter E. This assignment was always met with disbelief that it could even be done. I assured them that it could.

Why would I assign my students to do a lipogram? 

One of the benefits of such an exercise is that it forces you to slow down and think about each and every word you're using. Many writing problems are simply a result of being fast and sloppy. We are used to our language, and too often we think because we have spoken it almost all our lives, that we are masters of it. In a sense, we are, but if that were transferable, we wouldn't have so many people writing so many ungrammatical sentences--sentences they would never speak, as they simply could not speak them, they are so unnatural. 

That may seem an odd situation, but that is perhaps a topic for another post. I'll simply say that while acquiring speech is automatic and natural, writing is a technology that must be actively taught. 

Trying to write an essay without using words containing the letter E is a fun exercise. But imagine trying to write a short story without them. Or try a novel. Impossible? Tell that to Ernest Vincent Wright, author of Gadsby*, and to George Perec, author of A Void (Versa Mundi)*. Me, I simply tried to do it with a poem:

I am a lion, a high-soaring bird,
I'm coiling and hissing a softly hot word.
I am a spirit with amorous wings,
A mouth that can only spill words if it sings.
I am light, not shadow or gravity –
I am a painful and dark black cavity.
Do you know what all I say? I’m smiling
And as I laugh, do you know who I’m styling
My soul against? An abyssal dragon
Has flown into dark clouds and sky – an agon,
War whipping my soul into strong and hard
Long-living spirit that will always stand guard
And bring a gift for all of mankind. Gift?
It’s in a box, a box brought up from a rift,
A box I carry down and carry up –
I cannot touch lunch or drink from a cool cup
Until my body and my blood turn warm
And I unfold again my old human form.
A monstrous animal or living light –
A spirit that in its good growth fashions flight
From fast-growing wings that lift us aloft –
Shall all of us grow hard, or stupid, soft?
I had to go down to climb mountaintops,
This light gift . . . I laugh, so that no laughing stops.

You may be wondering how my students did. Many wrote some pretty terrible pieces (I only graded their ability to not use words with the letter E, to be fair in regards to the assignment), but a few wrote some very beautiful mini-essays. And everyone's writing improved dramatically on their next assignment.

Now, go out and write your own lipogram! It will be fun!

Thursday, July 7, 2022

Prose and Verse

 Broadly understood, any literary writer--including those who write novels, short stories, and plays--is a poet. We tend to make a distinction, though. Poets write in verse; novelists and playwrights write in prose. And while when we typically think of poetry nowadays we think of lyric poetry, poetry also comes in the forms of epic poetry--and plays.

What is the difference between prose and verse? It's difficult to make the distinction with a majority of contemporary poems being written in free verse. While there are certainly free verse poems that are verse, there are also those that are really prose with line breaks. The existence or absence of line breaks is not what distinguishes prose from verse.

So what, then, does distinguish them?

What you are reading in this blog post is prose. You speak in prose. Prose is language walking. 

Verse is more rhythmic. It may have very regular rhythms--like Iambic--or is may have more irregular rhythms, or have rhythms created by alliteration or sentence structures or numbers of syllables. In all of these cases, though, the language isn't walking. It's dancing. 

Of course, one can dance one's walk, and walk one's dance. 

Novelists like William Faulkner definitely dance their walk. Hemingway's dance is more subtle. 

If you want to read truly prosaic prose, I recommend a good scientific article. 

Most formalist poetry is dancing language. Walt Whitman's poems are very much dancing, though he's introducing a new kind of rhythm. Postmodern poets like Bob Perelman make their poems walk to such a degree that one could call their works prose with line breaks. 

Poets like Perelman and Margaret Atwood have a strong tendency to write what I would call prose with line breaks. This creates other demands on their poems, meaning they have to find other ways to make their works "poems," but to me at least it's clear they're not writing in verse. The presence of line breaks doesn't make a work verse.

I do believe, though, that all literary works of art at least dance their walk. There has to be some kind of rhythm. How else could a work of literature be beautiful? 

Syllabics

 If you were to come across a ten-syllable lined poem, you would probably expect it to be iambic pentameter. And you would probably be right...