Showing posts with label meter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label meter. Show all posts

Monday, January 30, 2023

Syllabics

 If you were to come across a ten-syllable lined poem, you would probably expect it to be iambic pentameter. And you would probably be right. However, regular meter is not the only possibility when creating a poem with a regular number of syllables. 

A poem with a regular number of syllables, but without meter, is known as a syllabic poem. There can be something charming in such a poem, where the regularity of the lines creates the pattern. The inclusion of other patterns--end rhymes and alliteration, for example--can bring a little more poetic order to the irregularity of the rhythms within the lines. 

Syllabics is hardly a new form for most people. Most people are familiar with the haiku, a popular Japanese form. The haiku is created by counting syllables and putting them into three lines. Five syllables, followed by seven, followed by five. (Note, a poem is only a haiku if it's a nature poem; if your 5-7-5 syllable poem isn't about nature, it's a senryu.) Thus, a haiku (or senryu) is a syllabic form. This is the case with many Chinese and Japanese forms, because of the sound structures of the languages. However, as the popularity of this form among Anglophone poets indicates, English can certainly fit well into these forms. 

How I Was Moved to Feed the Birds

The black grackle hopped
Up onto the patio
Its feet puddle-damp.

As you can see, the above is a proper haiku. If you are concerned about being too constricted by the number of syllables, you can always give it a nice, long title, as I have done with this one. Let me show you a poem in which I balance out the syllabics (10-count in this case) with rhyme:

Constructal Trees

I love the branching form of dicot trees--
Order, chaos, criticality please
The eye with expectation and a tease
Of difference. The bald cypresses have knees
That clear the water. Mangroves border seas
And branch above and below their trunks. Breeze
Brings movements to branches as their leaves seize
The air. A few have flowers, attract bees
And bats and birds and butterflies. Decrees
Are sung from their branches. We feel disease
If we're too far away from their firm lees
And their shadow darkening a few degrees
From the heat. And what other guarantees
Our air, ensuring that we do not wheeze
Through life? (Unless their pollen makes us sneeze.)
Complex beauty belongs to all of these--
We thus must always be all life's trustees.

The use of the same rhyme in each line is intended to box in the poem a little more, making up for the looseness of the syllabics. Of course, you don't have to do that at all. You can just leave it loose, which itself creates its own sonic feel:

 Rebirth

The man I was, the child I've become
Are separated by the gulf of Hell--
A sea-voyage past terrible islands,
Into storm-tosses seas of chaos--without
The benefit of the taste of Lethe.
Surrounded by black flames and spirits I
Wrestled with the Devil until I won
The right to sail from the storm and away
From the beautiful islands of joy--bliss
Blew in from the west to carry me, cold, 
Up to the rising sun creating new 
Horizons of rosy-red, orange, and gold 
Spread across the sea--evening's rainbow sea
Shining smooth in front of me in blue miles.
Nothing can be the same for me from now.
I have returned to these stone shores, reborn,
A child once again, I'm living wonder--
A child returned from graves of living men--
A child with eyes that learned to understand
In ways the man I was could never do,
Blinded by my dark, preconcepted world.
Now, I see the world I thought I knew--dark
Is light. I return to these shores, reborn. 

There are some who may, perhaps, consider this a kind of prose with line breaks (I have complained about such in the past), but the regularity of the line breaks creates a different feeling than if the line breaks were more irregular. This makes it something other than free verse. Forms are all created through regularities.

I think that syllabics are more interesting once you have mastered meter. There's a difference between creating syllabics because you want to and creating them because you don't know how to write in meter. I encourage you to work on mastering meter first, and then trying your hand at syllabics. There's a lot of potential in syllabics, but only among the most skilled at the other poetic forms. 

Monday, January 16, 2023

Bob and Wheel

Bardic Gawain: Sir Gawain and the Green Knight - YouTube

 Different languages have developed different poetic traditions because of the sound structures of those languages. For example, the Germanic languages had, early on, before the influence of Latin poetry and those of the Latinate languages (especially Italian and French), been dominated by alliterative forms. 

Alliteration is, of course, the repetition of initial sounds. The Old English poem, Beowulf, and those Norse Sagas written in verse are all alliterative. There are fewer words with end rhymes in the Germanic languages than in the Latinate languages, so as a consequence, other sound patterns emerged. Further, the languages are dominated by hard consonants, so it would be natural for hard consonants in particular to emerge as a rhythmic structuring device. 

In the Latinate languages, we find a lot of end rhymes. Thus, we should not be surprised to find that there is a lot of use of end rhymes in their poetry. Latin poetry was heavily influenced by Greek poetry, which emphasized rhythms such as iambic (which the Greeks considered to be a comic rhythm). As French and Latin entered into the English language, their styles of poetry did as well. Regular rhythms emerged, as did end rhyme. But of course, these things did not just happen overnight.

Thus, after the Norman conquest of England in the 11th Century, it's not surprising that we would find transitional poetry such as that of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight in the 14th century. While the main part of each stanza of The Green Knight is alliterative, each also ends with what is known as a "bob and wheel," in which regular rhythms and end rhyme come into play. 

All three translations I have of The Green Knight include the bob-and-wheel, but only two--Marie Borroff's and Brian Stone's translations--attempt to alliterate throughout the work, while W.S. Merwin's does not (nor do his bob-and-wheels rhyme correctly). The latter does, however, have the original on the facing page. We'll discuss issues of translation at a later date, so I will only note that in the tension between meaning and music, some translators tend toward one over the other. 

The stanza structure in The Green Knight is approximately 15-25 alliterative lines followed by a bob-and-wheel, which has the following structure:

rhythm    rhyme     structure

u/u/           a            bob
u/u/u/        b            wheel
u/u/u/        a            wheel
u/u/u/        b            wheel
u/u/u/        a            wheel

Here is an example of Stone's translation of stanza 30, the last two alliterative lines leading into the bob-and-wheel:

And there was none but said his nay, for never in their lives
Had they set eyes on someone of such hue
        As green.
    His way was wild and strange
    By dreary hill and dean.
    His mood would many times change
    Before that fane was seen. 

I would perhaps have made "many times" "often" in order to perfect the rhythm, but you get the idea of what this structure looks like. In any case, you will note that the bob is enjambed with the last line of the alliterative portion of the stanza. This ensures the continuity of the alliterative portion with the bob-and-wheel.

I've played with this structure myself, though I created a longer bob and a shorter wheel:

        Guide Light

        In the blue is the moon, a milk mass
        Whose place is purple dawn, a pregnant
        Betrayal of time and expectation
        When the sun is supposed to be set in the sapphire
        Alone to light our lives. Who's she
                Who'll be
                So free
            Beside the sun --
            Why won't she run?

        I thought the dark was destined to draw
        Me through my life, to thread and to threaten
        In ceaseless new moon nights that would nudge
        Me graveward and grant me a gravity that death
        Couldn't strangle out of me. Still the steel,
                Reveal
                The wheel
            That turned my life
            From death's blue knife.

        But the moon that is doubling the day will dip
        Into the night enough so that nothing
        Is encompassed by the dark that has come to claim
        My mind -- she will mend my heart and move
        Me to the dawn so the devils will dance
                The lance.
                Entrance
            Me to the day
            Where I can stay.

Certainly, there are other ways you can play with the bob-and-wheel structure, or you can simply use it as originally conceived. While alliteration has gotten a bad name in English poetry for a long time, I suspect that bad name has come about from a degree of Latin-based snobbery. I think there's probably a lot of potential still in alliterative verse, especially to the degree that it draws us into the Germanic origins of English through sound. More, I think there's something charming about the bob-and-wheel structure. It's something worth playing with. What can you create using this transitional structure? How might it become a transitional structure for you? 


Monday, November 21, 2022

Making Meter

*

In a previous lesson, I discussed the nature of meter. However, knowing what meter is and knowing why using it in poetry is important, and writing meter are hardly the same thing. Since these lessons are intended to help you write poetry, theory has to meet practice. 

There's a degree to which the English language follows a simple iambic pattern, which results in many people writing mostly iambic verse unconsciously. But art is supposed to be purposeful--at least, to a great degree. As an artist, I want to make sure that I am using the words I want to use, the rhythm I want to create, and so on. To this end, we need to try to understand how the English language naturally falls into certain rhythmic patterns. 

Most people have difficulty learning to write in rhythm. Many fall into writing free verse because of this difficulty. However, nobody should be writing free verse because they cannot write in iambic pentameter, trochaics, or whatever rhythmic patterns you can imagine. That is like becoming an abstract expressionist artist because you cannot draw. You're not making a choice in the matter--the lack of skill is what's directing what you do--and if you're not making a choice, you're not an artist. That's why getting all the fundamentals down is important. 

There are many words and syllables which are naturally stressed or unstressed. However, there is variability of how stressed a given syllable may be, and context can certainly matter. A weakly unstressed syllable or word can be pressed into becoming stressed by being surrounded by more strongly unstressed syllables/words. The same is true of stressed words and syllables--if a weakly-stressed syllable is surrounded by more strongly stressed syllables/words, it will become unstressed. To practice, though, it's probably good to try to stick with simple, clear stressed-unstressed syllables.

There are several shortcuts to getting a rhythm down in your poem.

The first thing to note is that the articles--a, an, the--are all unstressed words. 

   ˘ /

The rock

It's hard to push an article into being stressed, but hardly impossible. 

A word like "of" is typically going to be unstressed, but it can be easily pushed into being stressed. For example:

   ˘ / ˘ /

The Book of Forms

   ˘ / ˘ / ˘ / ˘

The Making of a Poem

In the above book titles, the rhythm of the word "of" is different because of the words which surround it. In the first, "book" and "forms" are both strongly stressed, so there's no question about whether or not "of" should be unstressed. In the second, "making" is stressed-unstressed, and "a" is unstressed. "Of" is thus surrounded by strongly unstressed syllables, pushing it into being slightly stressed. 

This can also happen within words. For example, the word "able" is stressed-unstressed. However, notice what happens when you make it a suffix of "believe":

 ˘ / ˘ /

believable

The strong stress of the second syllable of "believe" pushes the "a" of "able" into becoming unstressed, and the "ble" into becoming stressed. You'll note that this is very common in words with the suffix "able."

Indeed, the stresses in "believe" are strong enough that they will even turn a prefix such as "un," which is typically unstressed, into being stressed:

/ ˘ / ˘ /

unbelievable

Here, we have another example of a natural unstressed syllable, which is the suffix. Much of the time, both prefixes and suffixes are unstressed. (Ironically, the words "prefix" and "suffix" violate this general pattern.)

As just noted, prefixes are typically unstressed.

  ˘ / ˘ / ˘ /

unkempt        unloved       unfair

  ˘ / ˘ / ˘ / ˘

before            behind          befuddled

Notice that, though the "b" sound is a strong sound and might typically be part of a stressed syllable, the "be" prefix is nevertheless unstressed.

In "befuddled," we also see that the "ed" ending, when fully pronounced, is unstressed. This is typical of suffixes. If we take the stressed word "love," and add the "ly" suffix, we get

  / ˘

lovely

Suffixes added to a stressed word will thus be unstressed:

  / ˘.  / ˘    / ˘

granted          truly         walking

Again, the presence of an unstressed syllable at the end of the root word can press the suffix into being stressed:

/ ˘ / / ˘ /

fidgeted          nervously

As you can see, then, this is more an art than a science (it is poetry, after all). However, the general rule that articles, prefixes, and suffixes are unstressed will generally help you create regular meters. As you practice using very strongly stressed and unstressed words, you will eventually hear the rhythm and internalize it more and more. Once that happens, you can then play around with less clearly stressed and unstressed words and syllables, and play around with metrical patterns to create meaning in violations of a regular meter. 

The greatest art, including the greatest poetry, is balanced between regularity and irregularity. The variations within stressed and unstressed syllables themselves help to create additional music/rhythms on top of the regular rhythms of iambic, anapestic, trochaic, etc. meters. As you learn to hear the regularities, you'll start to write good, solid meter. Once you hear the regularities, you'll then be more able to hear the irregularities as well. And then, you'll start to write more complex, more beautiful meter--and do so more intentionally as well. 


Monday, September 5, 2022

Meter

*

Verse is metered language. What, though, is meter? 

"Meter" comes from the Ancient Greek "metron," meaning "measure." When we measure, or count, our lines, we are writing in meter. 

The simplest way to write meter is to simply count syllables. When we are writing poems with lines containing the same numbers of syllables, we are writing in what is called syllabics. In syllabics, we are not concerned about the placement of stressed and unstressed syllables or the length of syllables. These are common in languages which are not stressed, like Japanese, or tonal, like Chinese. However, in a language like English or German, our words are either stressed or unstressed. As a result, syllabics often sound stressed anyway.

Coincidentally, the Greek language, on which we have based most of our regular syllabic structures, wasn't stressed, but rather was made of long and short syllables. Such poetry is called quantitive verse. 

Most readers of poetry will be familiar with poetry with lines containing patterns of stressed and unstressed syllables, called feet. The best-known poetic foot in the English language is the iambic foot, which is a simple alternation of unstressed and stressed syllables. 

We mark stressed syllables with a "/" and unstressed syllables with a "˘", which sounds "da-DUM."

   ˘ / ˘ / ˘ / ˘ / ˘ /

Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?

  ˘ / ˘ / ˘ / ˘ / ˘ /

Thou art more lovely and more temperate!

Here, in Shakespeare's famous sonnet, we have lines of alternating iambic feet. Since there are five iambs, we call this a pentameter--"penta" for "five," meaning five-count. An iambic pentameter is thus a five-count of iambs. 

  • Dimeter: contains two metrical feet
  • Trimeter: contains three metrical feet
  • Tetrameter: contains four metrical feet
  • Pentameter: contains five metrical feet
  • Hexameter: contains six metrical feet

These are going to be the most typical meters. As Frederick Turner and Ernst Poppel argue in their essay The Neural Lyre (also found in Turner's book Natural Classicism, above), we're typically going to find the ten syllables of iambic or trochaic pentameter to be most "comfortable" in English because it fits into our auditory moment of about 3-4 seconds. If we're using anapest or spondee, then, a trimeter or tetrameter would fit that moment best. 

This, of course, gets us to the issue of regular rhythms. The most common regular rhythms in poetry are the following:

iamb:      ˘ / (ex: compare)

trochee: / ˘ (ex: summer)

spondee: / / (ex: Bang! Bang!)

anapest: ˘ ˘ / (ex: of unstressed)

dactyl: / ˘ ˘ (ex: beautiful)

There are, of course, others:

pyrrus: ˘ ˘

tribrach: ˘ ˘ ˘

amphibrach: ˘ / ˘

bacchius: ˘ / /

cretic: / ˘ /

antibacchus: / / ˘

molossus: / / /

The tribrach and the molossus are the most difficult to create because if there are three unstressed syllables in a row, we'll tend to hear one of the unstressed syllables as stressed; and equally, if there are three stressed syllables in a row, we'll tend to hear one of them as unstressed. To get your listener to hear a tribrach, you would likely have to have a very strongly stressed syllable on either side of it.

With most of these feet (excepting tribrach and molossus), you can use each of them to create a regular rhythm. With all of them, though, you can use them in combinations. For example, the Sapphic stanza is made up of three Sapphic lines and an adonic line. The Sapphic lines are two trochees, a dactyl, and two trochees, while the adonic line is a dactyl followed by a trochee. Thus, the Sapphic stanza is as follows:

/ ˘ / ˘ / ˘ ˘ / ˘ / ˘

/ ˘ / ˘ / ˘ ˘ / ˘ / ˘

/ ˘ / ˘ / ˘ ˘ / ˘ / ˘

/ ˘ ˘ / ˘

Note that the first three are 11-syllable lines (hendecasyllabics) in pentameters of mixed feet.

As one can imagine, there are a large number of potential combinations of syllabics, meters, and feet--an infinite variety if we ignore the requirement for the creation of line lengths that fit in the auditory moment. It's possible to create very complex meters and then repeat them in each line--or in alternating lines, or some other pattern. I would recommend that if you want to retain the word as a form of verse, though, that there be some kind of regularity--the simple and the complex have to be in balance--otherwise, you'll simply end up creating prose. And there's no need to figure out the meter and feet to write prose.

Another way meter is created is through the use of the caesura. A caesura is a pause in the middle of a line. The caesura helps to create a rhythm both within the lines and across the lines. If you use punctuation in the middle of your line, you'll create a natural caesura. But even without punctuation, the reader will create a natural (though weaker) pause in the middle of a long-enough line. While many English poems aren't built around caesuras, traditional Germanic (including Old English/Anglo-Saxon) verse was built around the caesura, with patterns of alliteration being determined by that internal pause.

Finally, in contradistinction to the caesura, where there's a pause in the middle of a line, there's enjambment, which means the syntax of a line isn't contained by that line, but is rather continued into the next line. Another way of putting it is that the line doesn't end with punctuation. The result is that a line that ends with punctuation is a harder pause than one without punctuation.

Regular number of syllables, feet, caesuras, and enjambment (and rhymes) are all ways to create meter, and to make for complex meters. It's important to both maintain regularity and disrupt that regularity simultaneously in order to prevent the reader from getting bored.

Remember, too, that changes in patterns are meaningful to the reader. Take advantage of that fact. If there's a change in feet (using a trochee instead of an iamb in a particular line, for example), then that word should probably be important. The same could be said of rhymes--your rhyming words should be more important than articles or prepositions, unless they're being used there for some kind of effect (meaning, they have meaning in being there).

Of course, there are also variations in stress--some syllables are more stressed than others, and this creates a more complex music over the regularity of the meter.

Things get even more complex if we read poems aloud, because then we add things like pitch, loudness, length, and timbre. Much of this will of course depend on how the reader chooses to read it, if the person has a high or low voice, if they think it would sound better loud or quiet, with longer or shorter time pronouncing given syllables, and personal, regional, or cultural speaking patterns.

All of this means that metered poetry is fundamentally musical. Encyclopedia Britannica's entry on rhythm even contains musical notation. This musicality brings both sides of the brain together--music and language--into a fuller, more complex art.

Verse is metered language. Meter is an artistic tool. It is what makes poetry a language art. The more we think about these kinds of rules, the more artistic our art will be.

Syllabics

 If you were to come across a ten-syllable lined poem, you would probably expect it to be iambic pentameter. And you would probably be right...