Showing posts with label emotion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label emotion. Show all posts

Monday, October 31, 2022

Against Self-Expression

If you search for images of "self-expression" on Google, you'll get a collage of photos that are going to look like this. I could think of no better way of showing exactly what I mean when I talk about--and criticize--self-expression. 

The irony here is that in all of this so-called self-expression, the results are almost universally identical. It's all a miss-mash, with lots of color. What this suggests is that everyone's self-expression is like everyone else's self-expression. And what does that mean for either the self or it's expression? It means you're just like everyone else if this is what self-expression looks like. And that's precisely the problem with self-expression as art. It isn't art. It isn't even, as one of the pictures suggests, self-love. Love is always of a particular thing or person, and if there's anything this example of self-expression is not, it's particular. 

 With that kind of introduction, it's probably not surprising that I would say that perhaps the worst thing that ever happened to poetry was the emergence of the cult of self-expression. Although one can find this cult at play in the other arts, it seems to have hit poetry the hardest, and ruined several generations of poets. 

Of course, the opposite end of this is the kind of academic poetry that is only produced in university English departments, only read by other academic poets, and only commented upon by academics trying to get scholarly papers published--a task made easier when one is dealing with "difficult" poetry. 

Karl Popper once defined true artists as those who are attempting to work out artistic ideas and problems--which is to say, those related to myth, structures, traditions, etc., in light of changing social conditions in which the artists are working. It is an evolutionary process, and it always is in touch with what came before it. 

Certainly, one could argue that contemporary academic poetry is doing precisely that. However, the avant-garde, as the academic poets fancy themselves to be, pride themselves in making radical breaks with the past. This is, of course, unlikely to be literally true, in much the same way that the surrealists never really allowed their "automatic writing" to go unaltered (a simple example: what are "automatic" line-breaks?). 

The real problem with what I'm calling academic poetry is that it, much like academic art in general, is created after the "artist's statement" is created--even if it's created only in the artist's head. This is in part the fault of most of our artists having become academic artists because they first passed through university classes. 

The funny thing, though, is that the undergrad poetry writing classes all tend to encourage "self-expression." The professors don't want you to stifle your self-expression by using form or any kind of constraint. In the meantime, many of them are writing poetry most of their students wouldn't understand. As the creative writers move into grad school, those who are writing more academic poetry tend to get more encouragement while the self-expression poets get left by the wayside. 

One of the main problems with self-expression poetry--and the reason it gets left by the wayside, and why most such poets eventually stop writing--is that there is really only so much self to express. Most people are like most other people. And really, almost nobody has anything particularly interesting to say--and if you do have something interesting to say, it's likely going to be said in a few poems, a few short stories. And then, you'll be done. 

While the academic poets do seemingly at least try to work out some kind of artistic problem, the problem they have is that they don't produce anything anyone wants to read. Not even the academics writing scholarly papers on today's academic art aren't interested in it. They just need to publish, and it's easier to publish something on a work that is contemporary and difficult and, therefore, hasn't been touched by anyone else, than it is to try to say something new about Shakespeare's sonnets, for example. 

This would seem to put us in a quandary. If self-expression doesn't create lasting art or artists, and academic poetry isn't going to be read by anyone, when where does that leave us? 

Fortunately, these are not the only options.

Another way forward is to first abandon self-expression as self-centered, narcissistic, and indulgent; then, we need to familiarize ourselves with the global traditions, become global classicists, and familiarize ourselves with the world's myths, poetic structures, and forms. We must keep in mind, though, that postmodern academic art is now part of that tradition. It was at least participating in the art of poetry in the Popperian sense, even if it sent itself into abject unpopularity due to the direction the poets went with it. However, to move forward, we have to bring things back to foundations, writing works that people would actually want to read, because they tap into the brain's love or rhythms, sounds/music, and archetypal imagery. Challenge, yes--but do so from a place of familiarity. 

None of this is to say that you will no longer appear in your poetry. How is that even possible? Your poetry is necessarily going to reflect your world view, your attitudes, your fundamental beliefs, your passions, and so on. How can they not? Just don't make the mistake of either thinking that your art is all about you, and do not think your poetry is going to change the world because you're undermining capitalism by subverting grammar or some such nonsense. You're not. That's not how poetry works. Its power is elsewhere. 

Remember, the Muses are the daughters of memory and inspiration, of what your brain retained of external knowledge, and the way your brain unconsciously processed that knowledge through your emotions. The "you," the "self" that is being expressed is in that unconscious processing leading to inspiration. It's not vomiting your emotions onto the page. Indeed, self-expression is the subversion of poetry to your emotions, ideas, and thoughts rather than entering into a dialogue with the world's other poets, and your audience. You have  to love the art enough that you want to serve it rather than make it serve you. And that means entering into the global history of poetry, bringing not just yourself, but your contemporary society, culture, and knowledge with you.

Monday, October 10, 2022

Alienation and Hating Poetry

*

In The Hatred of Poetry, Ben Lerner, a poet himself, makes the argument that people hate poetry because 1) they think that just because they are a language-using human, they ought to be poets themselves, and 2) actual poetry fails to live up to our ideal of Poetry. 

My gut reaction was that this was utter nonsense. However, I came to realize that there are a few other fields in which this is true. Take economics. Everyone thinks they ought to be able to make pronouncements about economist just because they are human beings, we buy and sell in the marketplace, we work, and so on. We make value judgments about people's behaviors, often envy those who are better off than us, and typically believe actual economies fail to live up to our ideal Economy. As a result, most people hate economics and economists. 

I would add to this psychology, sociology, and political science. 

At the same time, there are a number of areas where people don't make this same mistake: math, physics, chemistry, biology, and even many of the other arts, including sculpture and painting (though some Modernist and postmodern works have people saying, "I could have done that" or "My three year old could have done that"), music and acting are typically things we don't think we can do without some degree of expertise.

Why is it that people who don't read poetry and don't like poetry feel a need to express an opinion about poetry when those same people wouldn't do the same thing about recent publications in mathematics? It seems there are a set of things people do that others seem to hold in contempt because they fancy themselves able to do them, while there is another set of things people seem to admire (or at least not hold in contempt) simply because they know they couldn't possibly do them.

The reason people don't like poetry may have something to do with the fact that everyone thinks they can do it, and that bumps up against what actual poets are doing. Much like economists--everyone thinks they understand the economy, and they get mad when an economist comes along and tells them they're wrong about how they think the economy works. There is a disconnect between what the person thinks they can do and what the experts in fact do, between what the experts understand and what the average person understands. 

Why, then, do people who hate poetry love songs? After all, isn't a song really just a poem? Of course. But songs are more directly tied into music, and only rarely are songs constructed such that they are as complex as many poems often are. More, they are heard rather than read, and reading is a difficult cognitive process which we can only do because the brain itself reconstructs itself--certain parts of itself are already designed for other things--in order to be able to read. Then, what is read has to be passed through this section of the brain before it is sent to the language portions of the brain. The musical element poetry (when present) is suppressed relative to songs, so poems are neither really read nor sung while, at the same time, both read and sung. 

We can look at this in another way, by comparing Shakespeare read and Shakespeare viewed/heard. The same people who find Shakespeare "boring" when they read him are excited watching a play (or film). The same things that bore them when they read Shakespeare move them to fear or laughter or tears when they watch the play performed and hear the words spoken. Why is it boring when read and not boring when viewed (ignoring those who still find it boring when viewed, since other issues may be at play there--I am only interested in the disconnect between the attitudes of reading vs. hearing/viewing). This would point to my suggestion that, in the case of poetry, part of the disconnect comes about from the fact that poems are read, which makes them, in many ways, more complicated. 

The fact that poems are read rather than heard also invites contemplation and analysis. One can look at the words and think about their varied meanings. This further complicates one's relationship with poems. The more you interact with a poem, the less likely it seems you are able to write one. Yet, you are still convinced that you ought to be able to write a poem. It's all just language, after all, and you are a member of a language-using species. 

When we take literature classes, it's not uncommon to hear that poetry is a "higher" form of language. The problem is, if poetry is a "higher" form of language, and language makes us human, then poets are logically, it would seem, a "higher" form of human. Who wants to believe there are higher forms of human than themselves? Who doesn't want to be a higher form of human? Thus, many likely feel the poets are looking down on them more than a bit, and this breeds contempt, as all (perceived) elitist behavior breeds contempt for those exhibiting it. It probably doesn't help that many contemporary poets are in fact elites who love to flaunt their elitism in the creation of works that only fellow-poets are capable of understanding (or at least who claim to understand). This, perhaps, is one major source of hatred for (contemporary) poetry.

The same belief doesn't necessarily apply to painters. We may be impressed with the work of a painter, but we don't think the person is a "higher" form of human. We consider them to just be an artist expressing themselves. It's something we can't do, true, but for some reason we just chalk it up to practice or a skill we simply weren't born with. The fact is that, like artists, poets are just artists expressing themselves. Poetry writing is simply a skill honed through practice. There may be something in us that drives us to express ourselves--in our case, in language--but that again makes us no different from any other kind of artist. Language is our medium, but that fact doesn't necessarily make us a higher form of human. 

Lerner suggests that these attitudes many people feel toward poetry are a consequence of Plato's attitude toward poets. The Greeks considered poets to be inspired by the Muses, meaning they were conduits for the gods. They were chosen by the gods. Meaning they were special. This is another way in which people think poets are some kid of elite. While we in the West seem to still have that attitude, even if not quite expressed as God/the gods favoring the poets, the question is if other cultures hold this same view and thus think the same way about poets. Or, are their attitudes toward poets more like our attitudes toward painters and mathematicians? 

I would argue, then, that people tend to express contempt toward those things which they think ought to be easy, but which "experts" in the field keep demonstrating to be complex. They have respect for difficult things they think are difficult, and they likely don't think much at all about those things that they think are easy that are in fact easy (for pretty much everyone), or at least easy to understand. You might not be able to play the guitar, but rock music seems easy to understand. Jazz, on the other hand, is more difficult to understand, and as a result many people don't seem to much care for it (part of this may also be simple familiarity--as we learn to hear something, we grow to like it). 

Overall, I don't think that having or lacking interest in any of these particular things is what's at play here. There are sets of knowledge/skills we seem to respect and others which we do not. A person may not be able to do math, and may not personally like doing math, but still hold a great mathematician in high esteem. They're not going to engage in the math nor make the mistake of having an opinion about the math being done that they cannot do. As a result, they simply respect the mathematicians who can do those things. But when you have a person who is not an economist and is generally ignorant of economics, that doesn't mean they won't have an opinion about economics. The same person who lacks interest in learning math and economics will refrain from having an opinion about math and give their opinion about economics. 

So it seems that interest isn't really what's at play. Again, I think it's precisely the disconnect between apparent simplicity and the real complexity that creates this contempt toward poetry, economics, sociology, and psychology, among other things. I know I don't know anything about how to repair a car, so I respect auto mechanics. For the longest time I thought I could write and understand poems when I really couldn't. Thus, I started out with a hatred of poetry and a degree of contempt for poets--which has changed as I have slowly learned to understand poems and how to write them. I suppose I lost my hatred of poetry because I never really bought into the idea that there was this unattainable ideal of Poetry which can never be realized by any real poem. 

The less disconnect, the less alienation one feels, the less hatred one feels. That's probably something to consider in regards to things well beyond poetry. 

What do you think? Is there anything we contemporary poets can do to reduce the hatred of poetry, short of ostensibly "dumbing down" our poetry? Is the problem the way people write poetry, as esoteric texts? Is the real problem that contemporary poetry, like much contemporary art, is simply not perceived as beautiful? Is it because we only read and rarely ever listen to poetry? (Poetry slams are quite popular, and draw in non-poets, while poetry journals almost never draw in non-poets.) What can we do so readers are no longer alienated from our art?

Monday, September 12, 2022

Poetry, the Quadrivium, and the Trivium

The Trivium - The Regina Academies

The Trivium is part of a Medieval educational system that was designed to provide the student with a complete education. The Trivium is made up of grammar, rhetoric, and logic. The other part of that educational system was called the Quadrivium--arithmetic (number), geometry, astronomy, and music. 

You may be wondering what the Quadrivium could possibly do with poetry. Well, one can view geometry as number in space (patterns), music as number in time (rhythms), and astronomy as number in space and time. Using this formula, one could easily argue that well-written poetry is akin to astronomy, especially those poems that use things like iambic pentameter (note the use of number--"penta" means "five," which is the number of iambic syllable patterns in a line). As John Steinbeck once wrote, "Poetry is the mathematics of writing and closely kin to music." 

We have already spent a great deal of time discussing several aspects of the Quadrivium within poetry, even if we haven't exactly been calling it that, and we will spend even more on the issue of number in the future. However, for this lesson, I want us to focus on the Trivium.

Poets, perhaps more than anyone else (excepting lawyers), must master the Trivium. 

Mastery of grammar should be obvious: how can you be said to be a language artist if you have not mastered the language itself? Only if you fully know and understand why your language works the way it does can you properly use it, beautifully use it, twist and bend it. Thus, it is important that one understand how the different parts of speech work, what kinds of sentences there are, and how to diagram sentences. To be a poet, one must love language enough to want to know how the words and the sentences work.

I'm not going to be spending time on grammar lessons. That's not the point of this blog. I'm assuming you have mastered grammar and that you are here to learn about the tools you need to write poetry, and to give you some ideas about poetry writing, challenge the way you think about poetry, and provide you with my own ideas about poetry. However, there is much that can be said about the other elements--logic and rhetoric--and their importance to poetry.

First, logic. You may think that logic has nothing to do with poetry. You may even have some romantic idea that poetry transcends logic and reason. And you are, perhaps, right about the latter statement. But, in order to transcend something, you have to include it. But there is, as I have argued, a rationality in poetic verse. 

Poetry both infers and, in complex ways, demonstrates. Logic shows when inference and demonstrations are valid. We have to keep in mind that the word "logic" comes from the Greek "logos," which can be translated as word, account, thought, reason, idea, or principle. A dialogue thus occurs "through logos"--meaning there is necessarily a logic to dialogue, and thus to plays, which combine action with dialogue. Insofar as poetry is made up of words and ideas, and are products of our thoughts, it should be clear that we cannot avoid logic. Logic just clarifies our thinking. 

You have perhaps heard complaints about "logocentrism" and about logic itself. However, those who oppose "logocentrism" have to use logic to make their arguments. Those arguments can only be better or worse, and use good or bad logic, but logic is inescapable. Given this fact, I would argue that you should master logic--certainly before you can criticize it. And at least a familiarity with formal logic should benefit your thinking and, thus, your poetry. (Symbolic logic is another thing altogether--we'll leave that to the logicians over in the philosophy department.)

Rhetoric is the art of making an argument, the art of persuasion. Each work of art is trying to make some sort of argument, and the language arts perhaps more clearly and obviously. After all, we make most arguments using language. Thus, rhetoric is central to all forms of poetry. 

Aristotle argued that good rhetoric requires the use of logos, ethos, and pathos. 

Logos we have just covered. 

Ethos, from which we derive the word "ethics," has to do with the reader trusting the writer or speaker. Part of persuasion comes from your reader trusting you, and you can only create true trust by being a trustworthy person. How that can be demonstrated in a poem will certainly vary form poem to poem, from topic to topic, and is perhaps less tangible in poetry than in a scholarly paper or a speech. 

Pathos is emotion, how we create emotion in our writing or in a speech. We do not create true pathos by being melodramatic or sentimental. It has been said that sentimentality occurs when there's a lack of sentiment. Sentimentality if felt by the reader when the writer fails to communicate emotion well. One could perhaps say that sentimentality is pathos without ethos. 

It should be obvious that pathos is central to poetry. It's perhaps the one thing most early poets focus on--sometimes to the exclusion of all else. Which is why there is so much sentimental poetry out there. The way to create true pathos is through the use of appropriate imagery and through the use of story. But in the end, like most aspect of poetry, it takes practice to communicate emotions well, and you are bound to miss the mark on either side, by being either too sentimental or too cold. More, what works for one reader won't work for another. You just have to play the numbers--if you find a large-enough number of your readers get the emotion in the poem, you can consider it a success in its pathos. 

To be persuasive, you have to have good style. Of course, good style means different things for different kinds of writing. "A good style must, first of all, be clear. It must not be mean or above the dignity of the subject. It must be appropriate" (Aristotle). The style of an article intended for a mass audience is necessarily going to be different from that intended for scientists with advanced degrees, and both should be different for different kinds of novels, whether romance or literary, and everything in-between. And of course, poetry should itself have its own, and each poem should have its own, style. 

Style is more than just decoration. "Style ought to prove that one believes in an idea; not only that one thinks it but also feels it" (Nietzsche). The reader ought to be able to feel your conviction. Style, then, is part of the ethos of rhetoric. 

It is important for poets to master the Trivium. The Trivium must be mastered before you can challenge any part of it--if you decide to challenge any part of it. To paraphrase Don Barthelme, you have to be able to write masterfully well-written sentences before you can write bad sentences in your poetry or prose. Thus, it is important to know the rules of the language before one can challenge them. And challenge them we must for, as Octavio Paz once wrote, "Social criticism begins with grammar and the re-establishing of meanings." The greatest poets have always challenged the rules of grammar, logic, and rhetoric--and of ethos and pathos. But they have also always been their masters as well. 


Syllabics

 If you were to come across a ten-syllable lined poem, you would probably expect it to be iambic pentameter. And you would probably be right...